
Since yesterday seemed to be the 1B rumor day, I thought it only be fitting that I try to recap the multiple players available for the position.
The Mets are rumored to be looking for a platoon partner for Daniel Murphy at the position, this plan serves two purposes, get a longer look at Murphy at 1B and not block Ike Davis in 2010...
I must acknowledge that I don't like the idea, I've seen enough of Murphy that I believe he is more a Miguel Cairo type player then a starter. What I would do is sign Adam LaRoche to a two year contract with a third year option, this would outbid Atlanta who is only willing to reportedly go one year. Murphy could become a solid bench player while Davis has a great mentor in 2010 to make the transition slower as Wright had with Wiggy. LaRoche is a solid defender and has legitimate power for the position. Despite the Mets interest in him at the deadline, there has not been even a hint of interest this off-season.
Here is a quick recap of the names we have heard...
It appears the Mets are going to keep a close eye on Carlos Delgado and may offer him a contract if he plays well in PR. I'm torn on Delgado, part of me feels the team needs to move on but on the other hand you can't duplicate his production if healthy.
Nick Johnson is an injury risk, who's defensive skills slip in the second half last year and doesn't provide enough power for the position. Despite not appearing to be a fit the Mets are listed as a team interested in Johnson.
Reportedly the Mets checked in with Russell Branyan, the 34 y/o, hit .222 against lefties and had a dreadful second half with 9 HRs, .193BA. I believe Branyan's first half was more of a career year then a break out.
Jack Cust was brought up yesterday and while he only has 17 minor league games at 1B, his outfield defense is so bad I could see an NL team attempt to convert him to 1B to get his power bat in the line-up. I think he belongs in the American league as a DH.
A rumor I didn't cover yesterday was the idea that teams ( unnamed) have inquired whether
Jermaine Dye would play 1B.
Matt at Metsblog has a great post on the rumor. I've always liked Dye and during all those rumors over the years I wanted it to happen, I just wonder if that window has past especially at his age and at a new position.
Audrey Huff has been rumored to be on the Mets wish list; if Huff is his 2008 version where he hit .308 with 32 HRs and 108 RBIs then any team would welcome him but the next year Huff hit just .200 with 15 HRs. Depending on his cost he might be the best available platoon partner.
Xavior Nady has been linked to the Mets since his short stint with the team in 2006, the X-man is coming off his second TJ surgery and won't be ready to start the season. His arm may not allow him to play the outfield, he has over 100 major league games at 1B which may turn out to be his full-time position. My only concern with Nady is when will he actually return to the field, we don't need a guy who's return date keeps getting pushed back.
Hank Blalock was a rising star in Texas until injuries slowed his progress, but after two injury plagued seasons he returned last year healthy. Playing in 123 gms ( 66 gms at 1B) he hit 25 HRs with a .234 average. Blalock bats left and I don't see him as a full time candidate, he's also a big injury risk with a bad back.
If the Mets decided to go with leadership over offense then they could acquire Rich Aurilia and Kevin Millar ( I wouldn't go in that direction). They could also go for an all defense, great clubhouse guy in Doug Mientkiewicz but only do the Mets need offense but my understanding is Doug wasn't happy with the Mets in 2005. The of the free agent pool doesn't seem very appealing; Kevin Baker, Bobby Crosby, Jason Giambi, Brad Nelson, Nomar Garciaparra, Greg Norton, Jim Thole, Chad Tracy, Andy Tracy.
Now the
non-tender list because of the economy could be where the gems of the off-season are found. This list is incomplete but here's a look at a few of the names being discussed, if I'm looking for strikingly a low cost right handed platoon partner for Murphy that player might come from this group and not the big name guys above...
One of the best fits no longer appears available as the Marlins will keep Jorge Cantu, the 3B/1B is right handed and has decent power.
Conor Jackson lost all of last year with something called Valley Fever, he has the highest upside but I'm not sure if anyone knows enough about his condition for him to be worth the risk.
I like the idea of bringing in Garrett Atkins now that he's going to end up being non-tendered his cost won't be an issue since he'll get paid off his struggles from last year. Atkins is a change of scenery candidate as the team was already moving on to Ian Stewart. Prior to last year he had four above average seasons and he has a significant amount of time at 1B.
Another solid candidate is Ryan Garko who had a miserable time in SF after a mid-season trade. Garko is a decent right handed hitter and fielder while he could serve as an emergency catcher.
The Mets could always bring back Mike Jacobs but the warts he had in 2005 he still has in 2009 and he's a left hander.
Finally Andy Marte is no longer the top prospect who spent an off-season being traded around the league in one big deal after another. The 3B/1B continues to tare up AAA and then struggle in the majors...