
I understand Jerry Manuel's dilemma, this team without Beltran really has a line-up that doesn't fit together. If Angel Pagan starts, his only asset really seems to be in the lead-off spot, anywhere else and he's just going to be a runner left on base. But with Pagan in the lead-off spot and Jose Reyes in the three hole, that leaves Murphy a non-power guy to hit fifth just for the sake of breaking up the righties.
Now batting Reyes third has it advantages and disadvantages, he could become that free swinger who struck out a lot with a declining OBP ( 2004-2005 ish) if slugging gets into his head. But in a non-running spot in the order, he could ease his injured leg back into baseball.
There are two players who could drastically change this line-up and allow Reyes to remain in the lead-off spot, while still lengthening the order. Mike Jacobs and Gary Matthews Jr. if either or both rebound and win there respective position battles, the batting order could flow much better.
Angel Pagan drives managers crazy with his teasing potential and mental errors, couple that with Manuel propensity for veterans and Matthews has a true shot at CF which would put him in the fifth hole of the order. Jacobs is a longer shot at 1B but he's probably making the team, Jacobs is more of the power hitter that traditionally plays 1B in the NL and breaks up the right handed hitters in the power section of the order....
Line up 1- Pagan, Castillo, Reyes, Wright, Bay, Murphy, Francoeur, Barajas
Line up 2- Pagan, Castillo, Reyes, Wright, Bay, Jacobs, Francoeur, Barajas
Line up 3- Reyes, Castillo, Wright, Bay, Matthews, Murphy, Francoeur, Barajas
Line up 4- Reyes, Castillo, Wright, Bay, Jacobs, Francoeur, Matthews, Barajas
Moreover, Manuel's preference for veterans could further muddy the situation. Gary Matthews Jr. developed quite a reputation as a "gamer" around baseball after that catch in 2006. Manuel respects that sort of thing. He certainly respects it more than Pagan's reputation of being a bit clumsy on the basepaths and in the outfield. source Nj.com
First base is interesting. My guess is that the Mets will go with loyalty and name Daniel Murphy the starter. I just can't see Mike Jacobs not making this team. He's so a Met and his grit and determination so far this pre-season is unmatched. source Mack at NY Sports Dog